235 years. Zero soldiers on your couch. It’s time.

Repealthe Third

The case for repeal

27 reasons. One per amendment.

We are often asked why. A better question: why not? Since you asked anyway, here is the complete case, sorted into five fronts.

I

Front one

The Home Front

Every household has a list of things it has been meaning to do. Every soldier has been trained to do them before sunrise.

01

Hospital corners

Basic training teaches every recruit to make a bed tight enough to bounce a quarter off. Your guest bed has not been made since the Obama administration.

02

The dishes, finally

Kitchen Patrol is a time-honored military tradition. Your sink is a time-honored civilian disaster. These two things were meant to meet.

03

Snow removal

Our troops are trained to operate in Arctic conditions. Your driveway is, at worst, Lake Erie conditions.

04

Moving day

You will never again bribe a friend with pizza to carry a sleeper sofa up three flights. Infantry ruck marches carry heavier loads farther, uphill, for less pizza.

05

Grill discipline

Military cooks feed hundreds before dawn. Your brother-in-law burns six hot dogs every Fourth of July. The solution is constitutional.

06

The lawn, edged

Few institutions care about straight lines like the U.S. military. Your HOA will weep with joy. Then it will try to fine you for the Humvee.

II

Front two

The Heart

America does not have a housing shortage. It has a company shortage.

07

The loneliness epidemic

In 2023 the U.S. Surgeon General issued an advisory naming loneliness and isolation a public-health epidemic. Washington has studied it. We have a plan. It sleeps on a cot.

Source: HHS advisory
08

The empty nest

Millions of parents watched their kids leave and kept the bedrooms exactly as they were. Shrines to a 2014 boy band. Let someone use the bunk bed.

09

Thanksgiving, de-escalated

Your uncle has argued with everyone at the table. He has never argued with someone who outranks him. Watch him go quiet. Watch the stuffing get passed.

10

Homework help

The Army runs some of the largest training programs in the country. Your seventh grader is stuck on fractions. Introduce them.

11

Your dog has been asking

Dogs love structure, early walks, and anyone who throws a ball like a grenade. Your dog has a strong position on this amendment.

12

Pickup basketball

You need a fourth for two-on-two. You have needed a fourth since 2009. A whole fire team is available.

III

Front three

The Wallet

Fiscal conservatives and progressive housing advocates agree on almost nothing. Until now.

13

The barracks are not great

A 2023 Government Accountability Office report on military barracks documented mold, pests, broken heat and air conditioning, and plumbing failures. Your guest room has a ceiling fan and a decorative pillow that says “Gather.”

Source: GAO-23-105797
14

The housing allowance

The Pentagon pays billions every year in Basic Allowance for Housing so service members can rent off-base. Meanwhile your basement sits finished, carpeted and ignored.

15

The Quartering Credit

Our plan offers hosts a $1,791 annual tax credit, one dollar for every year from 0 A.D. to ratification. The accountants hate it. The historians love it.

See the plan
16

Better than Airbnb

An Airbnb guest leaves crumbs and a three-star review. A soldier leaves a made bed and, statistically, eventually a three-star general.

17

Property values

Realtors already list homes as “walkable” and “near schools.” Prepare for the most powerful phrase in real estate: garrisoned.

IV

Front four

The Constitution

We revere the Constitution. That is exactly why we want to tidy it up.

18

It has never been used

The Supreme Court has never decided a case on the Third Amendment. Cornell’s Legal Information Institute puts it plainly: there has been no Supreme Court explication of it.

Source: Constitution Annotated
19

It gets no respect

Law professor Glenn Reynolds called it “the Rodney Dangerfield of the Bill of Rights.” When your own fans are doing bits about you, it may be time to retire.

Source: 82 Tenn. L. Rev. 491
20

Repeal has precedent

In 1933 the Twenty-first Amendment repealed the Eighteenth and brought back beer. Repeal is not radical. Repeal is a party.

Source: Amendment XXI
21

The British are fine now

The amendment exists because of the Quartering Acts of 1765 and 1774. The country that passed them is now our closest ally. The threat model is two and a half centuries stale.

22

Constitutional decluttering

Twenty-seven amendments is a lot to memorize. Hold the Third in your hands. Does it spark joy? Thank it for its service. Place it gently in the bin.

23

Even a law professor asked

In 1991 Harvard’s Morton Horwitz published an article titled, in full, “Is the Third Amendment Obsolete?” Thirty-five years later, we are answering: yes.

Source: 26 Val. U. L. Rev. 209
V

Front five

The Nation

This is bigger than your guest room. This is about who we are.

24

The civil-military divide

Well under one percent of Americans serve on active duty. Most civilians have never shared a meal with a service member. We propose sharing every meal.

25

Recruiting

“Join the Army. See the world.” Old. Tired. Try: “Join the Army. Meet the Hendersons. They have a pool.”

26

Response times

Distributed basing is a serious military concept. Distributed basing into every cul-de-sac in America is our concept. Average response time: one hallway.

27

Because it’s America

What is more American than letting the people who defend your freedom sleep on your futon? What is more patriotic than a tired nineteen-year-old from Nebraska asleep under your grandmother’s afghan? The Founders gave us the power to amend. They would want us to use it on something.

I’m convinced. Pledge my couch.

Join the movement

A soldier is out there tonight sleeping in a barracks. Alone.