Questions & answers
You have questions. We have a guest room.
The most common questions we receive, answered with the seriousness they deserve.
Myth vs. fact
Setting the record straight.
The Third Amendment protects you from something.
Name one time. We’ll wait. We have been waiting since 1791.
Soldiers will eat all your food.
Yes. But they will also do the dishes, and at least it got eaten.
Repealing an amendment is impossible.
It has been done exactly once, in 1933. It brought back beer. Morale was excellent.
This is a fringe movement.
At least four strangers on Change.org and one on the White House petition site agree with us. That’s a coalition.
The Founders would hate this.
The Founders also gave us Article V so future Americans could fix their drafts. We are simply reviewing their work.
You’re not serious.
Correct. This is satire. The empty guest room is real, though.
Frequently asked
Is this real?
The Third Amendment is real. The quotes from senators, justices and members of Congress are real and linked to their sources. The petitions are real. The court cases are real. The movement is satire. Nobody is coming to your house. Full notice here.
Would I be forced to host a soldier?
Our proposed amendment repeals the Third Amendment, which would technically remove the consent requirement. Our plan would then immediately re-add consent through a federal sign-up sheet. Some critics call this “pointless.” We call it “a journey.”
Will the soldier bring a weapon into my home?
Weapons are stored in the armory. Your soldier will arrive with a duffel bag, a toiletry kit and an astonishing number of socks. Under the Host Bill of Rights, the most dangerous thing they may bring is an opinion about your thermostat.
Do I have to feed them?
You do not have to. You will want to. Nineteen-year-olds can sense a casserole from four miles away, and the look on their face when you say “there’s more” is, legally speaking, a form of national service.
Can I request a specific branch?
HostMatch™ allows branch preferences. Army hosts report a lot of early mornings. Navy hosts report a lot of very organized cabinets. Air Force hosts report that their soldier asked about the Wi-Fi before saying hello. Marines have been known to sleep in the yard by choice. Coast Guard hosts report someone who is very good with the boat you forgot you own.
Is the Space Force eligible?
Yes. Space Force guardians will be quartered in homes with telescopes, skylights or, failing that, a very good TV.
What about my HOA?
The Constitution outranks your homeowners’ association. This is the single strongest argument we have and it polls extremely well.
I live in a studio apartment.
Under our plan, studio residents may sponsor a soldier’s stay elsewhere by contributing a casserole. Or you can pledge your couch. It’s a studio. Your couch is your guest room, your dining room and, let’s be honest, your bed.
Does this apply in time of war?
The Third Amendment already allows quartering in wartime “in a manner to be prescribed by law.” So in a way, the Founders already agreed with us. We’re just asking them to commit.
What do actual soldiers think?
We have not asked them. Many service members would, very reasonably, prefer their own place, their own fridge, and no one asking them to look at vacation photos. That is why every soldier in our plan gets the right to politely decline, which, if you think about it, is what the Third Amendment should have said in the first place.
Why not repeal a different amendment?
We are a single-issue movement. Other amendments have lobbyists, advocacy groups and cable-news segments. The Third has a joke Facebook group and an Onion article. It is the only amendment we could take on and win.
Has an amendment ever been repealed before?
Once. The Twenty-first Amendment repealed the Eighteenth (Prohibition) in 1933. It is the only time it has happened. It went very well. Ask any bar.
Where does my donation go?
Nowhere. We won’t take it. Try it and see, then send it to Fisher House instead.
Is this website affiliated with the military or the government?
No. Not with the Department of Defense, any branch of the Armed Forces, any member of Congress, any court or any political party. Images of service members on this site were generated for illustration and do not depict real people.