235 years. Zero soldiers on your couch. It’s time.

Repealthe Third

Know your opponent

The Quartering Caucus.

These are real statements by real officials, quoted word for word from Senate transcripts and the Congressional Record, with links. Some were defending the Third Amendment. Some were joking. All of them are wrong, and we can prove it with feelings.

0

modern officials on the record

0

Supreme Court justices among them

0

who have offered a guest room

0

bills ever filed to repeal it. We would be the first.

Supreme Court

Neil Gorsuch

Then a nominee, now Associate Justice · Senate Judiciary confirmation hearing · March 21, 2017

“No quartering of troops. Stay out of my house with your troops.”

Earlier in the same hearing he added: “The Third Amendment, which I am glad we do not litigate much.”

Our response

Justice, you are glad it isn’t litigated much. So are we. That is the entire point. An amendment nobody litigates is an amendment nobody needs. You made our case under oath, on C-SPAN, in front of the whole Senate Judiciary Committee.

As for staying out of your house: noted. We will put you down as “guest room, undecided.”

Source: Senate hearing transcript (CHRG-115shrg28638)
Senate

Sen. Ben Sasse (R-NE)

Same hearing · March 21, 2017 · after Gorsuch urged high schoolers to look up the Third Amendment

“And get 20 bucks out of your pocket at the same time.”

Our response

The senator implies the Third Amendment protects your wallet. Our plan does the opposite: the Quartering Credit puts $1,791 into it. Twenty bucks is not a constitutional principle. It is a tank of gas in 2017.

Source: Senate hearing transcript
Senate

Sen. Chris Coons (D-DE)

Same hearing · March 21, 2017

“although obscure, it is still beloved by some in the first State.”

Our response

“Obscure.” “Beloved by some.” In Delaware. Senator, with respect, that is not a defense. That is a description of a minor-league mascot. Delaware has a lot of beach houses that sit empty from September to May. We have done the math.

Source: Senate hearing transcript
Senate

Sen. John Kennedy (R-LA)

Gorsuch hearing · March 22, 2017

“the Third Amendment. I do not remember the language. It is quartering troops.”

Our response

A sitting United States senator, on the Judiciary Committee, at a Supreme Court confirmation hearing, could not remember the language. It is thirty-two words. We rest our case. Then we pick it back up, because this is fun.

Source: Senate hearing transcript
Supreme Court

John Roberts

Then a nominee, now Chief Justice · confirmation hearing · September 13, 2005

“the Third Amendment, protecting their homes against the quartering of troops.”

Cited as one of the sources of a constitutional right to privacy.

Our response

Privacy is important. That is why every soldier in our program gets a door that closes. The Chief Justice’s privacy concerns are about the government barging in. Ours is an invitation. There is a difference between a home invasion and a sleepover.

Source: Roberts hearing transcript, p. 147
Supreme Court

Antonin Scalia

Associate Justice · Senate Judiciary hearing, “Considering the Role of Judges” · October 5, 2011

“no quartering of troops in homes, etc.—the marvelous provisions of the Bill of Rights.”

Scalia listed it among the freedoms Americans cite, then argued that the Bill of Rights is not what makes America free; the structure of government is.

Our response

We consider Justice Scalia a secret ally. He called the provision “marvelous,” then told the Senate that lists of rights are not what keep a country free. Translation: you can lose one and be fine. He said “etc.” about it. You do not say “etc.” about something you would die for.

Source: Senate hearing transcript (CHRG-112shrg70991)
Supreme Court

Brett Kavanaugh

Then a nominee, now Associate Justice · confirmation hearing · September 6, 2018

“The Third Amendment not much mitigated [sic], as we know, Senator, but you can trace it.”

The official transcript prints “mitigated.” He almost certainly said “litigated.”

Our response

Not much litigated. Not much mitigated. Not much anything. When a future Supreme Court Justice’s strongest statement is “you can trace it,” you are not looking at a pillar of liberty. You are looking at a genealogy hobby.

Source: Senate hearing transcript (CHRG-115shrg32765)
Senate

Sen. Dick Durbin (D-IL)

Elena Kagan confirmation hearing · June 29, 2010

“We’re kind of stunned to see that he even went to the Third Amendment”

On Justice Douglas citing the Third Amendment in Griswold v. Connecticut.

Our response

The Senate’s number-two Democrat was stunned that anyone would reach for the Third Amendment. Senator, we agree. We are building a whole movement around how stunning it is that it still exists.

Source: Senate hearing transcript (CHRG-111shrg67622)
House

Rep. Adam Kinzinger (R-IL)

Fox News interview · June 2020 · on National Guard troops moved out of D.C. hotels

“Has nothing to do with quartering in the Third Amendment.”

Our response

The congressman, himself an Air National Guard pilot, argued a hotel stay is not quartering. Fine. Then here is our question: if the government can put a soldier in a Marriott, why can’t you put one in your Marriott-themed guest room? You have the little soaps. You have been saving them for years.

Source: Fox News
House

Rep. Chip Roy (R-TX)

House floor · July 26, 2021 · opposing door-to-door COVID vaccine outreach

“by, in the Third Amendment, preventing the quartering of troops in the homes of American people”

Our response

The congressman invoked the Third Amendment against federal workers knocking on doors. Knocking. Not moving in. Not unpacking. If knocking is quartering, the Girl Scouts are a standing army. We respect the passion. We recommend a dictionary.

Source: Congressional Record, H3900
House

Rep. Chris Gibson (R-NY)

House floor, “American Freedoms” · September 14, 2016

“the king had quartered troops in our homes. He did that without asking; didn’t pay us any money.”

Our response

This is the most important statement on this page, and it is on our side. The congressman’s objection was two things: without asking, and didn’t pay. Our plan asks, and it pays. Congressman Gibson, a retired Army colonel, has accidentally written our platform.

Source: Congressional Record, H5486
House

Rep. Tim Burchett (R-TN)

Statement to Fox News Digital · June 2023

“If he’s not going to uphold the Second Amendment, what’s next? The First Amendment, the Third Amendment, where are we going with it?”

Our response

Where are we going with it, Congressman? We are going to the Senate. Then to thirty-eight state legislatures. You laid out a slippery slope and put the Third Amendment at the bottom of it. We are at the bottom of the slope, and it is lovely down here. We have snacks.

Source: Fox News
House

Rep. Warren Davidson (R-OH)

H.R. 7742, the “Defending Freedom Act of 2020” · introduced July 23, 2020

“The government is ever-present, in violation of the Third Amendment.”

Finding 11 of the bill, which argues phone and car location tracking puts the government inside your home.

Our response

The only bill in modern memory to invoke the Third Amendment argues the government is already in your home, via Bluetooth. If that is true, the amendment has already failed. If the government is ever-present, it might as well take out the recycling.

Source: H.R. 7742 text
Founding era

Patrick Henry

Virginia ratifying convention · June 16, 1788

“They may be billeted in any manner—to tyrannize, oppress, and crush us.”

Our response

Mr. Henry was describing soldiers of a hostile empire. Today’s soldiers are your neighbor’s kid, the guy from your church, the girl who used to bag your groceries. If Specialist Kayleigh from the Piggly Wiggly is your idea of tyranny, the problem is not the Constitution.

Source: The Founders’ Constitution

Unlikely allies

People who, when you think about it, basically agree with us

  • Judge Irving Kaufman, dissenting in part in Engblom v. Carey (1982), called the Third Amendment claim in that case “far-fetched.”
  • Professor Morton Horwitz asked, in a 1991 law review title, “Is the Third Amendment Obsolete?” He asked. We answered.
  • Professor Glenn Reynolds called it “the Rodney Dangerfield of the Bill of Rights, getting no respect.”
  • Judge Andrew Gordon (D. Nev., 2015) ruled that a police officer “is not a soldier for purposes of the Third Amendment,” shrinking its reach even further.
  • At least four Change.org petitioners and one person on the Obama White House petition site have already called for repeal. Read them.

Join the movement

A soldier is out there tonight sleeping in a barracks. Alone.